Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shane's avatar

I find so much value in your posts, and I appreciate your freedom to write them when you feel you need to. I agree the Great Simplification feels a little lost in the woods right now. I worry Nate is burning out on some level. I enjoyed the Schmachtenberger episode, but afterwards I realised he hadn't actually said anything more than "raise awareness" in a very pleasant and round about way, and I wondered if my instincts that it is too late for that to do much good are right or not. He has developed the cadence of a preacher which I find unnerving at times.

If you see 8 billion blissful frogs boiling slowly in a pot are you really doing them a favour pointing out their ever worsening suffering, especially if the >90% of the frogs are physically unable to jump out of the pot?

The questions keep returning- How do people change? Can people even choose to change? Did I even change on this journey, or did I suspect something was deeply wrong with the world from day one and this is just the natural consequence of that abnormal instinct? Is there any reason to change beyond a certain point? A lot of smokers with terminal lung cancer keep on smoking to their last day. Their logic seems correct to me. Maybe the suburbanites sucking down every last drop of self destructive dopamine are on the best of all possible paths for them.

Maybe those of us who have jumped out of the pot already are all that are going to do so. At some point this will be true, when the water is too hot to survive anymore. Maybe that is just the way it has to be, and our compassion and urge to save others will reach its practical limit. Maybe us enlightened ones are merely sitting on the edge of the pot, where there might be a slight breeze to cool our heads while our feet are put to the fire. If you were sentenced to be burnt alive there would be no advantage in demanding that only your waist down was consigned to the flames. Quite the opposite in that particular scenario.

Expand full comment
And Now What's avatar

The cracks in the walls are getting bigger and more difficult to ignore, but the house still stands - for now. We know it's coming down soon, though - and count our blessings while we still enjoy them. That includes reading your posts, safe on my couch, with the 20 year old cat that we recently adopted between me and the screen. What you share about 'getting it in your heart' touches me. It is the intensity of experiences and the letting go of (big) ambitions that you describe that resonates. Everything has been said, the die has been cast. And yet, our words still have the power to connect us and heal. Our gestures still can inspire and comfort. Our grief still speaks of our love for this wonderful planet. The birds still sing their song - be it not in a magnificent dawn chorus as I remember from my childhood. A single butterfly can make me marvel. That intensity. My heart gets it, too...

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts